Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Beauty Subscription Smackdown Part 3: Ipsy vs. Birchbox February 2015

February was a busy month for me (sorry I suck at being on time with these guys). Several birthdays to remember (including my own and Johns), Valentines day and some other important dates in my life are in February but I'm still as excited as ever to get my subscription boxes so let's get into it!


I'm going to start with Birchbox, now for the last boxes I've gotten I've noticed one things that has really bothered me--they keep showing sneak peeks of amazing products to be in the box but then I get stuff that I'm not all the excited about. However I peaked this month (unable to contain my excitement) and I'm pretty excited to say that this month Birchbox may give ipsy a run for their money.



Keeping up with their promise of beautiful boxes, the February Birchbox has put a modern twist on their theme "Friendship" with this box using text blurbs. I think it's pretty cute so like the others I will be keeping this box.


Juice Beauty Blemish Clearing Cleanser $2.63- I'm not sure if it was hormones or the product itself but I broke out so bad while I was using this. I was excited to see this brand and the sample size is decent. It was lightly foaming, which I like, but I just wasn't that impressed. I think I may try this again in a few weeks and see if it makes a difference.


Gilchrist & Soams Spa Therapy Body Wash $2.53- So I haven't tried this yet, but I do like that I get travel-convent sizes in subscription boxes. I will most likely save this for a trip with John.The scent is nice and pretty gender neutral so we'll probably share it.


The Balm Cosmetics Read My Lips Lip Gloss (BAM!) $4- As much as I've always wanted to try some The Balm products I rarely wear lip gloss. I like the color and the texture but I just don't wear things like this to work or running errands, so it doesn't get a ton of use. Still it's a great color and texture and the size is fantastic for a lip gloss sample.


Beauty Blender and Mini Solid Cleanser $25- I was very excited when I saw this was coming in my box. I have had one beauty blender in my whole makeup life and when it died I was unable to justify a new one. Since then I have been searching for a cheaper dupe but no such luck yet. I defiantly love this product and I'm glad to have a new one. As for the cleanser I haven't tried that yet but I'm excited to get the chance.


BeeKind Conditioner (1.87) $- Again this is another product I will most likely keep for traveling. I'm not really one for conditioners that I use in the shower so I couldn't really tell you how well this works. However I do have to say that I'm very disappointed in the packaging since it isn't resealable.


Box Total:$36.03 So I wasn't super excited about this box but it wasn't necessarily a miss for me either. I think I will eventually use these products but for the most part I'm just going to travel with them at some point. Obviously I liked the Beauty Blender and that definitely made up for the other not-so-exciting products.

Now Onto Ipsy...

This Month's Theme was #IpsyLove. Quite frankly the theme wasn't all that exciting to me and it did sound pretty cheesy but I did like the bag design. I thought that it was really cute and it feels super sturdy.



So here's what came in the bag:

City Color Cosmetics Creamy Lip Stain (Flirtini) $4.99- The texture if this is a lot thicker than I was expecting. It still feels light weigh which was surprising as was how comfortable this was to have on. I wish the stain lasted a little longer on the lips but it does stay fresh looking for a few hours. Overall the product was good for what is was but not something I would purchase in the future.


Emite Makeup Professional Eyelash Curler $25- The reviews I saw on this made me nervous because everyone was talking about how it chopped off their eyelashes. Ipsy did send out an email about some being defective. I have not had any such problems with this. It actually fits really well to my eye shape and is comfortable to use. I wouldn't say it changed my mind about spending lots on a lash curler since it didn't curl my lashes a lot and I much prefer my Andrea's Choice one.


Eva NYC Up All Night Volumizing Spray $10- Unfortunately I haven't been able to try this yet.
On the directions it does say to use before blow drying to add volume or on styled hair to revitalize the look. I haven't blow dried or styled my hair since I got my bag but I didn't need another blow dry thing. I have 3 but I guess I'm stocking up. Regardless I'm still excited to try.


Mitchell and Peach Fine Radiance Face Oil $17- I wasn't sure if I was excited to try this or not. On one hand my skin is very sensitive and I break out easily. On the other hand I've been interested in face oils for a while since they are supposed to be good for your skin. I ended up loving this. I use it after my nightly cleansing mask to hydrate my skin and it leaves my face so soft. I will definitely be buying more.


Model Co. Blush Cheek Powder (Cosmopolitan) $9.42- This is such a pretty color. Lately I've really been into softer pinks for blushes and this is no exception. It sheers out beautify for a more natural look or it can build up nicely to a very barbie pink color. This is definitely my new favorite blush.


Bag Total $66.41 As a whole I really enjoyed this months bag. I think I got some products that  I will continue to get great use out of. I liked that I got a mixture of makeup, skincare and hair and the value is hard to beat!

The winner is...IPSY! Again I just think that Ipsy had the better month. I got some awesome samples, great spring colors, a tool, skincare that works great, and some more hair products to try. I think they had some quality products and a great mix this month. Birchbox also sent out awesome brands and I am still very excited about it but it just wasn't as exciting to me as Ipsy.

If you are interested in signing up for either of these boxes my referral links can be found to the left of this post! Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed!

xoxo
Courtney

Monday, March 2, 2015

Beauty Subscription Smackdown Part 3: Ipsy Vs. Birchbox January 2015

I'm so sorry I'm late with this one guys and yeah, I know. I know. This is probably one of the most overdone competitions in Beauty Subscription history. Who hasn't done Ipsy vs Birchbox? But I felt like I had to do it, if I really want to explore all the options that are out there. If you want to know a little more about the companies, you can find my post on that here. But other than that let's get started.






                 VS





Starting with Birchbox....This month's theme was "Let's Do This!"



So in case you didn't know, this is actually my second Birchbox. My first one was December, but since I had already completed the smackdown for that month and I was in the last month of Ipsy vs Lip Monthly (update coming soon) I decided to hold off on that review. Birch Box has announced that every box this year will be decorative so that is cool and I am very excited.  I have so far not been too impressed with Birchbox, but it hasn't been a total let down either... so let's get to this!


Wish Shave Cream (Acai Grapefruit) $2.93- As horrible as this is going to sound, I haven't shaved with anything but my electric razor in several months. I've honestly just been way too busy and it takes a lower priority. I will probably just keep this in my travel toiletries, since I generally use conditioner to shave with anyway as a cheaper alternative.


Number 4 Non-Aerosol Hairspray $4.50- This was a decent hairspray and it didn't leave my hair too crunchy, but it also didn't have too much hold so it wasn't too impressive for our weather. However I really do like non Aerosol hairsprays, especially in this format with the pump for travel. I will be keeping this for an upcoming trip.


Tocca Cream Da Mano Hand Cream (Grapefruit Cucumber) $5- I love little tiny hand cream samples and this one is very nice. It is highly perfumed and has a strong scent but I enjoy it although it's probably not for everyone. It seems to soak into my skin fairly quickly and it fits nicely into my purse. This is quite possibly my favorite item out of the box.


Coastal Scents Revealed Palette Sampler (Latte) $1 (Estimated Price)- Seriously? A Coastal Scents sample? Admittedly the colors are a nice neutral selection and I could create some really great looks with it, but I have a lot of similar products so I think this will be held onto for traveling since it's so small.


Harvey Prince Sincerely Perfume $0.55-This was a major let down. I hate perfume samples like this. It's just so disappointing because I can go into a store anywhere where I live and get these for free. Plus I don't wear perfume a lot so this was a huge bummer. It doesn't smell bad but I'm just not interested in trying perfume.


Total Box Value $13.98- I was pretty let down by this box. I expected to be wowed and really happy, but it turns out I'm really only happy about one item, the rest are going into a tub full of stuff I take on trips. Except the perfume, that's going to a friend. The theme this month was really inspiring and sparked a conversation between John and I- we've decided to join a gym and finally shed those extra pounds. But the products were kind of forgotten.



Now onto Ipsy:

This Month's theme was "Fresh Start"



The idea of this theme wasn't all that interesting to me considering we did "Fresh Picks" last year. I definitely see what they were going for, but I wasn't all that excited about it. As for the bag...eh, not my favorite. I'm actually using it to hold some old costume jewelry that I am going to remake.

Bellá Pierre Shimmer Powder (celebration) $14.99-Lately I haven't been too big on shimmer products but this is a nice gold color. It's very flattering with my blue eyes and looks nice against my skin tone, I probably wont use it a lot but it would be nice for date night.


Elizabeth Mott All Over Shadow Brush $9.99- I'm always happy to have another brush and I really love this brand so I'm always excited to get something from them. This brush is very soft  and dense so it packs on shadow nicely. I'm actually pretty impressed, plus it's not a bad price point and it feels really sturdy.


La Fresh Eco Beauty Be Good. Good Day. Day Moisturizer.  $12- Is it just me or is this brand getting more and more expensive? I'm really not a big fan of their products and my skin is very sensitive. It breaks out often with new products, and I have not had good luck with this brand in the past. I did end up passing this onto John.


Pacifica Natural Mineral Coconut Eyeshadow (Ethereal) $2.80- Honestly I wasn't super excited about the Pacifica, we've sampled this formula before, and though it's a beautiful color I just don't like how chalky it feels. It's got a subtle shimmer which is pretty but I will probably pass this along to a friend.

Probellè  Nail Lacquer (Into The Blue) $6- Lately I've been gravitating away from the bright colored nail polish in place of some nice neutral more nude colors, however this broke that pattern. I love the color and I've gotten so many compliments while wearing it. It did chip within a few days which is a bummer, but I'm really hard on my nails. I wasn't excited about this at first but now it's one of my favorite products from this months bag.


Total Bag Value $45.78- Even though I don't like the bag itself, I really felt like we got a good selection of products this month. I'm enjoying 3/5 products this month which in my opinion is a win. I also think the bag value for January is amazing. I can't wait to see what February brings.


And January's winner is...Ipsy! Between the two, I feel like Ipsy actually offered better samples. I was happy that nothing I got in my Ipsy bag was something I could walk into a store and sample for free. Though I'm not thrilled with everything in the bag, I feel like I got a much better value and more products that I will get use out of. Birchbox has yet to really impress me, but we have two more boxes to go for this part of the smackdown series.

Hope you enjoyed this month's smackdown. If you want to sign up for either of these boxes feel free to use my referral links below:

                                                    Ipsy                            Birchbox

xoxo
Courtney